An empirical study of organized
retailers and their impact on consumer’s buying behavior
Dr. Atul Pandey1, Dr. Sachin Bhardwaj2, Mr. Sanjay Mishra3
1Prof In-Charge BBA and M. Phil. Programme, APSU, Rewa (M.P.)
2Asst. Prof., Department of Management, MIT
Moradabad (U.P.)
3Head, Dept. of Mgt., Lotus Business
School, Pune (MH)
*Corresponding Author E-mail: atulpandey1@yahoo.com;
sachinmba04@gmail.com; sanjay15061973@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Estimated to be worth more than
US$ 500 billion, the Indian retail industry is considered as one of the world’s
top five retail markets in terms of economic value. The industry is
experiencing exponential growth, with retail development taking place not just
in major cities and metros, but also in Tier-II and Tier-III cities. India's
strong growth fundamentals along with increased urbanisation
and consumerism have opened up immense scope for retail expansion. Further,
easy availability of Debit/ Credit cards has contributed significantly to a
strong and growing online consumer culture in India. With the online medium of
retail gaining more and more acceptance, there is a tremendous growth
opportunity for retail companies, both domestic and international. Currently,
the online retail penetration in India stands at around 60 per cent, according
to a report by an industrial body.“India has a young, well-educated and
professional population, core customers. It has a very good market. We chose to
be in India before China,” as per Mr Jonathan D Caplan, President and Chief Executive, Genesco Inc.
Objective of the research study:
·
To study organized retail industry in India.
·
To study organized retailer and services provided by them.
·
To examine the impact of services provided by organize retailers an its impact on consumer buying behavour.
Research Methodology
Two stage sampling plan has been
used for collecting data from the retailers. In the first stage four big cities
and four small cities of Madhya Pradesh have been selected on the basis of
convenience sampling. The cities have been divided into urban and sub urban
category. In the urban cities I have selected Bhopal, Indore, Gwalior and
Jabalpur. In sub urban city I have selected Rewa, Sidhi, Shahdol and Ujjain. In the
second stage 10 samples from each city are taken on the basis of convenience
random sampling.
KEYWORDS: Orgasnised retail, Tier II and Tier III
cities, FDI, Foreign players, Urbanization.
Retail
industry is basically that sector of the economy which is engaged in selling
finished products to end consumers. Most of the goods sold are made by some
third party though these days big retail chains have introduced their brand
line as well which is known as private labels. As per the AT Kearney ranking,
India is at number four in the list of thirty emerging countries for retail
development.
Basically there are three kinds of retailers that are generally
available1 –
·
Organized Retail – These are owned by private or
government and are based on some principles and procedures like Wal-Mart, Big
Bazaar. Possess license to sell the product.
·
Unorganized Retail – Owned by an individual and
they are also based on some principles.
·
Grey Market – Unauthorized small stores
that are owned by an individual. They are not bound by any principles or rules
as they are run illegally.
Organized retailers often many
advantages which an unorganized store could not offer e.g. consumer now has a
wider range of choices of goods, better shopping experience, more convenient
and many other benefits. They also offer great discounts with some supermarkets
offering more than 5% below MRP whereas unorganized stores generally sell
products at MRP. The number of SKUs available is also much more than that
available in unorganized stores and so there are less problems of stock out or no
stock. The farmers have also benefited from organized retailing as they are in
direct touch with the retailers and resulting in bypassing of the
intermediaries who used to eat away the margin of both retailer and farmer. In
a way they have helped in boosting the growth of other sectors which are
related to them like agriculture, manufacturing etc. Companies are also in
direct touch with the customer and so they have better awareness that which
products are selling and which are consuming the shelf space. It has also
enhanced the employment potential by providing direct employment to many people
who are involved in many activities that take place during organized retailing.
In organized retail sector we
generally have modern format stores which include supermarkets, hypermarkets,
discount stores, departmental stores, shopping malls and similar kind of
stores. While in unorganized sector we have small kirana
stores which are the local shops that are owned and operated on a small scale
generally in a limited space. Owners themselves operate it so it has the
benefit of low operational costs. As they are in the near locality they have
better understanding of customer requirements.
In India it was in 1995 when
organized retail finally started taking shape when the Indian government had
started relaxing policies and market liberalization was taking place. The
sector has undoubtedly drawn benefit in that period because of the
liberalization as the government is encouraging more and more FDIs into the
country. At that time almost 90-95% of the retail sector was still unorganized
in India. The sector continued to flourish encouraging many Indian
industrialists to enter into organized retail sector.
The sector reached its peak growth in 2006 when consumers were
more seeking organized retail format and there was greater exposure to foreign
brands. The retail shopping districts started developing and more shopping
centers, lifestyle malls and shopping complexes have emerged offering people
shopping, entertainment and food chains at the same place. This concept first
took shape in tier I cities but soon it spread into tier II and III cities as
well. Many bigwigs have become popular in this industry including Big Bazaar,
Reliance Fresh, Nilgiris, More and many others
Right now the industry has
reached its matured phase with growing Indian economy. Salary is expected to
rise by an average of 13% and consumer spending is expected to increase by 12%.
As per the emerging trends, the disposable income of people has increased over
the time which is expected to grow further and they are spending more than
earlier. There has been an increase in working population in the range of 19-60
years which is expected to reach 620 million in 2012. Even young people are
purchasing more and have become specific about from where they are purchasing.
At this point of time, organized retailers are focusing more on tier II and III
cities where there is still scope of further growth. Retail companies are now
emphasizing more on increasing their presence in the new emerging retail
formats such as supermarkets, convenience stores, hypermarkets and specialty
stores.
As per the Business Monitor
International (BMI) India Retail Report, the total retail sales in India is
expected to grow from US$ 395.96 billion in 2011 to US$ 785.12 billion by 2015.
This is all due to the increase in earning and spending power of people and as
a result many international companies including Wal-Mart are planning to enter
into retailing in India which will boost the competition in the retail
industry.
The growth of organized retail
in India
The Indian retail industry has experienced high growth over the
last decade with a noticeable shift towards organised
retailing formats. The industry is moving towards a modern concept of
retailing. The size of India's retail market was estimated at US$ 435 billion
in 2010. Of this, US$ 414 billion (95% of the market) was traditional retail
and US$ 21 billion (5% of the market) was organized retail. India's retail
market is expected to grow at 7% over the next 10 years, reaching a size of US$
850 billion by 2020. Traditional retail is expected to grow at 5% and reach a
size of US$ 650 billion (76%), while organized retail is expected to grow at
25% and reach a size of US$ 200 billion by 2020.
The US-based global management consulting firm, A T Kearney, in
its Global Retail Development Index (GRDI) 2011, has ranked India as the fourth
most attractive nation for retail investment, among 30 emerging markets. As
India’s retail industry is aggressively expanding itself, great demand for real
estate is being created. The cumulative retail demand for real estate across
India is expected to reach 43 million square feet by 2013. Around 46 per cent
of the total estimated demand between 2009 and 2013 will be come from Tier-1
cities. For instance, Pantaloon Retail added 2.26 million square feet (sq. ft.)
of retail space during the fiscal 2011 and booked over 9 million sq. ft of
retail space to fructify its expansion plans in future.
Sector
Prospects
The
penetration of organized retail will happen much faster in the coming decade,
even in tier 2 and tier 3 Indian cities, because of the changing demographics
of India’s population and a healthy rate of economic growth. With good
underlying economic growth, increase in disposable income, increased awareness
due to penetration of broadband and mobile devices with internet accessibility,
the demand for consumer goods will rise. With better systems and processes in
place, all this is bound to assist in increasing the penetration of the
organized retail sector in India.
Rural
retailing is also poised to grow multifold in India. With several states in the
country permitting retailers to purchase produce directly from farmers, the
farmers too are adapting to the new opportunity to cultivate assigned crops and
take special care of the same. This gets them instant credit at higher prices
than what they received from the erstwhile traders/middlemen. Corporate
retailers like ITC, Godrej, Reliance, AV Birla, Mahindra and Mahindra and many
others have already established the farm linkages.
India’s rural markets offer a sea
of an opportunity for the Retail sector. According to National Council of
Applied Economic Research (NCAER)2 reports, rural India is home to
720 million consumers across 627,000 villages. 17% of these villages account
for 50% of the rural population as well as 60% of rural wealth. This implies
that reaching out to just 100,000 plus villages will ensure access to most of
the rural opportunity.
Some of
the key players in the Indian retail market, with a dominant share are3:
|
Name of holding company |
Prime Banners |
|
Pantaloon Retail |
·
Pantaloons ·
Central ·
Brand Factory ·
Ezone ·
Hometown ·
Planet sports ·
Bigbazar ·
Foodbazar ·
KB’s Fair Price Shop |
|
K Raheja Group |
·
Shoppers stop ·
Crossword, ·
Inorbit ·
Hyper city |
|
Tata Group |
·
Croma ·
Landmark ·
Poltrona Frau Group Design Center ·
Star Bazaar ·
Tashi ·
Westside |
|
RPG Group |
·
Spencer’s ·
Books and Beyond ·
MusicWorld |
|
Landmark Group |
·
Centrepoint ·
Babyshop ·
Splash ·
Shoe Mart ·
Lifestyle ·
Beautybay ·
Iconic ·
Q Home Décor ·
Candelite ·
Max ·
Shoexpress ·
Emax ·
Lifestyle Department Stores ·
SPAR hypermarkets ·
Landmark International ·
Footwear Division |
|
Parimal Group |
·
Piramyd Megastore ·
Piramyd Supermarket ·
Jamin |
|
Reliance |
·
Reliance Fresh ·
Reliance Trends ·
Reliance FootPrint ·
Reliance Digital |
- Carrefour which opened its first cash-and-carry store in
India in New Delhi.
- Germany-based Metro Cash and Carry which opened six
wholesale centers in the country.
- Walmart in a JV with Bharti Retail, owner of Easy Day store—plans
to invest about US$ 2.5 billion over
the next five years to add about 10 million sq ft of retail space in the
country.
- British retailer Tesco Plc (TSCO) in 2008, signed an
agreement with Trent Ltd. (TRENT), the retail arm of India’s Tata Group, to set
up cash-and-carry stores.
- Marks and Spencers have a JV
with Reliance retail.
The Indian retail sector accounts for 22 per cent of the country's
gross domestic product (GDP) and contributes to 8 per cent of the total
employment. India continues to be among the most attractive investment
propositions for global retailers. Cumulative foreign direct investment (FDI)
inflows in single-brand retail trading, during April 2000 to June 2011, stood
at US$ 69.26 million. Till now FDI up to 100 per cent was allowed for cash and
carry wholesale trading and export trading under the automatic route, and FDI
up to 51 per cent was allowed in single-brand products, with prior government
approvals. However, the Government recently passed a cabinet note and permitted
FDI upto 51% in multibrand
retailing with prior Government approval and 100% in single brand retailing
thus further liberalizing the sector. This policy initiative is expected to
provide further fillip to the growth of the sector.
OBJECTIVE OF THE RESEARCH STUDY:
·
To study organized retail industry in India.
·
To study organized retailer and services provided by them.
·
To examine the impact of services provided by organize retailers an its impact on consumer buying behavour.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY:
Two stage sampling plan has been
used for collecting data from the retailerss. In the
first stage four big cities and four small cities of Madhya Pradesh have been
selected on the basis of convenience sampling. The cities have been divided
into urban and sub urban category. In the urban cities I have selected Bhopal,
Indore, Gwalior and Jabalpur. In sub urban city I have selected Rewa, Sidhi, Shahdol
and Ujjain. In the second stage 10 samples from each city are taken on the
basis of convenience random sampling.
HYPOTHESIS:
H01 There is no significant difference
in the facility provided by the different retailers of organised
brands
|
S.No. |
Facilities |
Big Bazaar |
V Mart |
Reliance Mart |
Koutons |
|
1. |
Home delivery |
23 |
35 |
28 |
14 |
|
2. |
Better and free parking |
52 |
38 |
25 |
22 |
|
3. |
Accepting credit cards |
68 |
32 |
45 |
71 |
|
4. |
Trial rooms |
0 |
0 |
0 |
89 |
|
5. |
Food zone |
45 |
27 |
46 |
0 |
|
|
Total |
188 |
132 |
144 |
196 |
|
Retail
store |
Of |
Ef |
Of
- Ef |
(Of
- Ef)2/ Ef |
|
Big
Bazaar |
188 |
203.57 |
-15.57 |
1.190868 |
|
Reliance |
132 |
217.8 |
-85.8 |
33.8 |
|
V Mart |
144 |
237.6 |
-93.6 |
36.87273 |
|
Koutons |
196 |
658.97 |
-462.97 |
325.267 |
|
chi
square value |
397.1306 |
|||
The tabulated value of chi square for 6 df
at 95% level of confidence is 21.026 but the calculated value (397.13) is
greater than the tabulated value. Hence, undertaken hypothesis is rejected. So,
There is significant difference in the facility provided by the different
retailers of organized brands
CONCLUSION:
The Indian organized retail
sector's impact changed the lifestyle of the Indian
consumers drastically. The evident increase in consumerist activity is colossal
which has already chipped out a money making recess for the Indian
organized retail sector. With the onset of a globalized economy in India,
the Indian consumer's psyche has been changed. People have become
aware of the value of money. Nowadays the Indian consumers are well
versed with the concepts about quality of products and services. These demands
are the visible impacts of the Indian organized retail sector. Since
the liberalization policy of 1990, the Indian economy, and its
consumers are getting whiff of the latest national and international products,
with the help of print and electronic media. The social changes with the
rapid economic growth due to trained personnel, fast modernization,
and enhanced availableness of retail space is the positive effects
of liberalization. The non-food sector, segments comprising apparel,
accessories, fashion, lifestyle felt the significant change with the emergence
of new stores formats like convenience stores, mini marts, mini
supermarkets, large supermarkets, and hyper marts. Even food retailing has
became an important retail business in the national arena, with large
format retail stores, establishing stores all over India. With the entry of
packaged foods like MTR, ITC Ashirbad, fast foods
chains like McDonald's, KFC, beverage parlors like Nescafe, Tata Tea, Café
Coffee and Barista, the Indian food habits has been altered.
REFERENCES:
1. Guruswamy Mohan, Sharma Kamal,Mohanty J.P., Korah Thomas
J., FDI in India’s retail secotr more bad than good,
CPAS, New Delhi
2. Kalhan Anuradha,
impact of malls on small shops and Hawkers,Economic
and Political weekly, June 2, 2007
3. Business Line. 2007. ITC to take retail biz
Received on 08.01.2014 Modified on 12.01.2014
Accepted on 24.01.2014 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Management 5(2):
April-June, 2014 page 121-124